One case I wanted to highlight talks about Cyntoia Brown, a Black woman, was convicted in 2006 at the age of 16 for the murder of Johnny Allen, a man who had picked her up for sex in Nashville, Tennessee. Brown claimed that she shot him in self-defense after he attempted to sexually assault her. Brown had been a victim of sex trafficking, which played a significant role in her actions. Her case went largely unnoticed until years later, when celebrities and activists began advocating for her release, pointing out the injustice of sentencing a juvenile to life without parole in such circumstances.
Initially convicted of murder and sentenced to life in prison, Cyntoia Brown's case gained widespread attention around 2018. Advocates, including high-profile figures such as Kim Kardashian, highlighted the injustices of the criminal justice system regarding juvenile sentencing, especially for Black women. After serving 15 years, Brown was granted clemency in 2019 by Tennessee Governor Bill Haslam, largely due to the public outcry over her case and the growing recognition of her being a victim of trafficking.
In the early years of her imprisonment, Brown was often portrayed as a dangerous criminal. Media coverage largely ignored the details of her victimization, focusing on her actions instead. However, as more activists, celebrities, and public figures began to advocate for her, the narrative shifted. The media began to focus on her youth, her status as a trafficking victim, and the flaws in the justice system that led to her severe sentencing. Brown's eventual release was framed as a victory for criminal justice reform.
After serving 15 years in prison, Cyntoia Brown was released in 2019 after Governor Haslam granted her clemency. Her case sparked wider discussions about juvenile justice reform and the treatment of women of color in the criminal justice system. Brown’s story was also a key case in the broader movement to address the issue of juvenile sentencing, especially in cases involving trafficked children. You can learn more here. When we look at Cyntoia's case, we know that if she were to be white, her cases would've been handled faster and easier.
On the other hand, In 2016, Brock Turner, a white male Stanford University student, was convicted of sexually assaulting an unconscious woman, Emily Doe (later revealed as Chanel Miller), behind a dumpster on campus. Turner was caught by two witnesses who saw him assaulting Miller and held him until the police arrived.
Turner was convicted of three felony charges of sexual assault but received a highly controversial sentence of just six months in county jail, with the judge citing concerns about his future and the impact of a lengthy prison sentence on his life. The leniency of the sentence led to public outrage, and after serving only three months, Turner was released.
Initially, media outlets often framed Turner as a "promising young man" whose life was ruined by a single mistake, and the case sparked debate about white privilege and the justice system's treatment of affluent young white men. The victim's identity was initially kept anonymous, and the media focus was on Turner's potential rather than the gravity of the crime.
Turner’s sentence was widely criticized as insufficient, especially given the severity of the crime. In the aftermath of the case, Chanel Miller came forward and wrote a memoir, "Know My Name," which illuminated the personal impact of the assault and the legal system’s failings. The case sparked wider conversations about sexual assault, privilege, and the criminal justice system. You can read more here.
Compare and Contrast
When looking at both cases, we can tell that Brock Turner is white male Stanford student, Turner’s case attracted national attention due to his status as an athlete and student at a prestigious university. The media often centered on his potential and the privilege afforded to him as a white, affluent individual. And Cyntoia Brown is a Black female, Brown's case highlighted issues of race, gender, and the exploitation of young women, particularly those who are victims of sex trafficking. Her case was scrutinized for how the justice system treats women of color, especially those who are juveniles.
In contrast, when dealing with legal treatment, it's shown that Despite being convicted of serious crimes, Turner received a controversial and lenient sentence, which was widely seen as an example of how the justice system favors white, privileged individuals. His brief sentence was framed in terms of rehabilitation and concern for his future. But Brown was sentenced to life in prison for a crime committed when she was a teenager, despite being a victim of trafficking and abuse. Her lengthy sentence, without the possibility of parole for many years, sparked calls for reform. It took public outcry and high-profile advocacy for her case to be reconsidered, leading to her release after 15 years.
Lastly, we look at the outcomes of each of these cases and think hello??? Turner served only three months in jail for a serious crime that left his victim, Chanel Miller, traumatized. His sentence was widely seen as unjust, and his early release highlighted disparities in how the criminal justice system treats white men, especially those from privileged backgrounds. On the other hand, Brown served 15 years in prison before receiving clemency. Her case led to significant public outcry and discussions about reforming the juvenile justice system, particularly for those who are victims of sex trafficking and abuse. Brown’s release was celebrated as a victory for criminal justice reform, though it raised important questions about how race and gender affect sentencing.
Comentários